

Before I get into how tantalizing a thought the above image is (and it is very, very tantalizing), let's talk about Guy Ritchie.

Guy Ritchie is a man of many mistakes. Well, one really. He married Madonna and fell victim to Gavin Rosdale Syndrome (a debilitating disease in which an otherwise affable and talented bloke is turned into a baby-sitter by his hot and famous pop-star wife.) Ritchie is responsible for two of the coolest movies of all time (Lock, Stock & 2 Smoking Barrels and Snatch) as well as one of the worst (Swept Away, his Madge-starring remake of the classic Italian film that left him in director jail obscurity.)
The man who helped make Jason Statham a household(ish) name tried making a comeback with Revolver, a mixed-reviewed movie I still haven't seen but apparently am not exactly missing out on. Now, it appears, the man who made quick-cuts, cockney accents and shaggy-dog heist stories a humorously post-modern genre all their own has weaseled his way into a comeback.
I say "weaseled" because, in all honesty, the only reason Ritchie's latest film RockNRolla is getting even the slightest hint of a buzz is because it stars Gerard Butler, the 300 star Warner Bros. would have hired Hitler to direct if it meant they could keep some more of that Sparta money coming their way. Joel Silver was so pleased with the new (as yet unreleased) film that he let leak that he wanted Guy to helm his long-in-development adaptation of the legendary WWII-set DC Comic Sgt. Rock.

Now, there's a concept I can get behind. A man who is really good at having people shoot each other with witty one-liners doing a WWII film based on a comic book. That actually sounds like a greenlight waiting to happen. Then Warner Bros. (a company who I lose little droplets of respect for with every passing day) announced that they want Guy to direct their latest hope at a new franchise: SHERLOCK FUCKING HOLMES.
Okay. Now, I love me some Arthur Conan Doyle. Sherlock is one of my favorite characters in literary history. His mythology is rich and he's just fucking cool. It's been ages since Hollywood made a serviceable adaptation of any of his stories (unless you count the entirety of Law & Order: Criminal Intent which is, for the most part anyway, just Dick Wolf and former showrunner Rene Balcer remaking Sherlock as a neurotic NYPD Detective.) I just have one qualm.

Guy Ritchie is good at a great many things (well, that's a stretch,) but nuanced mystery has yet to be proven among them. There's pretty much only one individual that could get signed and get me excited about this project.
NOW BACK TO THAT PICTURE:
Robert Downey Jr. is one of the few, proud actors in Hollywood that can play pretty much any part given to him. A lot of people think of Johnny Depp when they think of that type of actor, but fuck him. I like him, sure, but he's no Bobby DJ (yes, I just made up that nickname. Feel free to co-sign.) Now that Iron Man is making hundreds of millions of dollars, Downey is finally A-List after 20+ years in the biz. That means he's getting asked to join more projects than the only smart kid in a science class in the slums.
Of those projects (which include another detective franchise and a fantasy movie from the guy who did Seabiscuit, and a movie about cowboys and aliens titled, yes, Cowboys & Aliens) the only one I think could sufficiently supplement Iron Man is Sherlock.
Who else could imbue the part with the charm, intellect, wit and presence needed to make Sherlock a modern, kick-ass action hero (something I'm guessing WB wants to do if they have Guy fucking Ritchie directing based on some unpublished comic that casts Holmes as more swashbuckling than junkie-know-it-all.)
Personally, I think this movie has serious potential. I just hope they get someone who isn't Guy to pen the script (preferably someone with gravitas, like The Queen's Peter Morgan, or a master craftsman like Michael Clayton scribe Tony Gilroy) and don't go too far in the direction of making Sherlock James Bond.
They could always take a page out of the Green Hornet sidekick dynamic playbook and have Jason Statham play Watson as an ass-kicking, McDreamy-esque doctor who aids his friend Sherlock by kicking dudes in the head and driving expensive, European cars very, very fast.
Either way, this franchise has serious potential, so long as they don't replace all the interesting subtlety of the Holmes mythology with British gangsters and explosions. Well, not TOO many explosions, anyway.









