
Edgar Wright saved my life once.
Okay, that's not quite true. Edgar Wright saved my life loads of times. His work (
Shaun of the Dead,
Hot Fuzz, the awesomeness that is
Spaced) is the type of pop culture madness that nerds wish they were capable of creating on their own. He is a geek God of massive proportions.
That is why when I heard he'd be adapting Bryan Lee O'Malley's graphic novel opus
Scott Pilgrim's Precious Little Life I flipped my fucking shit. I literally had a coronary. If you've never read any of the Scott Pilgrim books:
A) I hate you and we can't be friends anymore.
B) Seriously, you can't even come to my housewarming Party.
C) I don't care if you brought beer.
D) Stop reading this and go buy the books.
Scott Pilgrim is a 23 year old Canadian slacker who must do battle with his new girlfriend's seven evil ex-boyfriends in order to keep dating her. Yes, it is exactly as awesome as it sounds, only moreso.
Bryan Lee O'Malley has given us the perfect synthesis of everything I love. Indie rock, video games, manga, unrequited romance. I seriously cannot think of a series as brilliant as this one to come from the world of comics in forever.
So, to recap: Edgar Wright + Scott Pilgrim = Super Happy Funtime - $10.
One of my best friends and I once spent forty-five minutes at a Red Robin eating fries and dream casting the upcoming Scott Pilgrim movie. We did one serious casting session, and one mostly utilizing friends of ours we thought would be good fits (seriously, Ryan McGovern could totally play Scott.)
Alas, none of our nerd babble included Michael Cera, who is actually going to BE playing Scott Pilgrim. He's the only official cast member so far, and I can't disagree with his signing.


He's commercially viable, funny, talented, about the right age, and not a bad fit (sorry, McGovern.)
So, with that in mind, I'm going to round out the cast myself. Its up to Wright & Co. to listen to me or not, but I've had this fucking movie stuck in my head for the past hour and this is the only way I see fit to get it out.
NOTE: I'm well aware that the film is supposed to be an adaptation of all six volumes of the book, but in my world, this would be a film series a la Harry Potter, only less twee and more awesome.
Here goes...
RAMONA FLOWERS


Zooey Deschanelwasn't my first choice, only because I really couldn't decide who could pull this part off. Ramona is an enigmatic character. She's got to be desirable, clever, badass, and kind of off-putting. You need to love Ramona in one scene, root for her in a fight in another, and still be suspicious of how good she is for Scott.
Some message board nerd mentioned Zooey and I was a little unsure. I love She & Him Volume 1, and all of her movies are pretty great. My test was basically to re-read key scenes in the GNs with Zooey's voice, and she passed. Also, she'd be cool with a big ass hammer.
KIM PINE


I'd like to think her having previously worked with Michael Cera has nothing to do with me wanting to cast Ellen Page as the drummer in Scott's band, Sex Bob-omb, but I'm not sure I can say that with certainty. Ellen page just has cynical side that is perfect for Kim, the resident sarcasm spewing, surly seductress that used to date Scott and now has dreams of him being killed.
That and I'd like to see her with red hair.
STEPHEN STILLS


James Franco might be a little old for our cast, but I can't think of anyone else who could embody this character. He's laidback, charismatic, cool, and Stephen's relationship with girlfriend Julie Powers just reminds me alot of the one James Franco had on
Freaks and Geeks with Kim Kelly.
YOUNG NEIL


Basically, Jorma looks young-ish, innocent and vacant. Fucker'd only have like three lines in the whole movie. He doesn't pass the "looks like a younger scott" test is Cera is cast, but I'm feeling him for this.
KNIVES CHAU


I know I already cast Julia Ling as Aja in my fake Jem movie, but I really love this girl. She had a bit part on an old episode of Aaron Sorkin's short-lived
Studio 60 On The Sunset Strip and she was very Knives-esque, which is to say she was young, cute, Asian and kind of scary.
WALLACE WELLS


Joseph Gordon-Levitt, for no other reason than he is awesome in everything he does now and I think he'd make a funny gay roommate. He looks a little like Wallace, and I can see him really playing up the boozy, weirdness Scott has to put up with.
STACEY PILGRIM


Alia Shawkat is the only piece of Michael Cera-bating casting decision-stuff. I just think it'd be cute if she played his sister after sort of doing it for a few years on
Arrested Development. She doesn't look too much like Stacey, but she's got the right personality, and really needs the work. She's like the only person from that show not getting good parts. Well, other than Portia de Rossi, but who really gives a flying fuck?
JULIE POWERS


Leighton Meester is already such a cunt on
Gossip Girl (or so I'm told) that it wouldn't be a stretch for her to be Stephen Stills' on-again-off-again girlfriend who apparently hates all of her friends.
NATALIE 'ENVY' ADAMS


Nora Zehetner was born to play Envy. If you don't believe me, watch
Brick. She could play that arc of lovely and unassuming into epic, amazonian level bitch. Nora's a heartbreaker, and she'd look good in those boots.
LISA MILLER


I'm not sure how good she'd look blonde, but Camilla Belle has that cuteness that Lisa Miller needs. I can totally see her re-emerging into Scott's life, dressing just slutty enough to get noticed, but being very coy and flirty.
HOLLIE & JOSEPH




Kat Denning just has that Hollie feel to me, even though I only know her for being Catherine Keener's daughter in
The 40-Year Old Virgin. Jesse Eisenberg gay and with a beard is just too funny and opportunity to pass up (neither pictured, but seriously, Jesse + Beard = Funny).
LYNETTE GUYCOTT


I kind of want to sleep with new singer Ingrid Michaelson, which has no bearing whatsoever on me casting her in those small part. That, and I think she really does have a bionic arm.
MATTHEW PATEL


I so want to be the guy who DOESN'T say Kal Penn for this, but I'm just that lazy. Actually, Aziz Ansari would be alot funnier. Go, Clell Tickle!
LUCAS LEE


The dickheaded pro-skater turned pro-actor is basically a jab at Jason Lee anyway. Why not pay him for it?
TODD INGRAM


Ed Westwick already plays a handsome, over-confident prick on
Gossip Girl(yes, I watched it, alright? Back the fuck off.) I'd love to see him pull of the vegan psychic powers and the exploding-into-an-extra-life headbutt.
ROXANNE RICHTER

Emma Stone isn't quite zaftig enough to play the plus-size, Half-Ninja ex-girlfriend Ramona tried to keep secret, but what girl wouldn't accept a role where she gets paid to put on a few? Emma's got the right about of zing and could probably pull of that chip on the shoulder, college-phase lesbian thing.
GIDEON

Keith Murray, frontman of dance-rock-pop-punkers We Are Scientists, is not an actor, but he is funny. I mean, he covered a Nickelback song. Also, I think he's harboring the kind of vitriol it would take to send a bunch of evil ex-boyfriends at an unassuming slacker.
BONUS
Scott Pilgrim & The Totally Awesome Soundtracky Mixtape
1. Scott Pilgrim - Plumtree
MP32. Chick Habit - April March
MP33. You're No Rock N Roll Fun - Sleater-Kinney
MP34. Ex-Girlfriend - No Doubt
MP35. Nrrrd Grrrl - MC Chris
MP36. Bastards Of Young - The Replacements
MP37. Ballad Of A Comeback Kid - New Pornographers
MP38. Girlfriend In A Coma - The Smiths
MP39. Nobody Move, Nobody Gets Hurt - We Are Scientists
MP310. Scott Pilgrim's Sad Restaurant Song - Matthew Seely
MP3